Product Review
Dry ice: It’s so cold it burns. It goes straight from a solid to a gas. It creates eerie fog and wicked bubbles.
In other words, dry ice is perfect for science experiments that kids will talk about forever.
So Summer Counts jumped on the opportunity to review Steve Spangler’s New Ultimate Dry Ice Kit.
We partnered up with Mr. Stidger, a go-getting science teacher from Pine Lane Primary (Parker, Colorado), to see if what puts the Ultimate in this kit and what could be done in an ordinary classroom.
Mr. Stidger received the kit a couple of days before our science lesson, to sort through the contents and look over the accompanying lesson material.
Mr. Stidger is no stranger to the Spangler curriculum and immediately recognized a few traits that are typical with this vendor’s curriculum; like the funny introductions that kids love, and the standards alignments that teachers appreciate. He quickly pulled together a few of his favorite dry-ice experiments, which he calls the “Spangler’s All Stars Collection,” and got ready to try it out on the schools 5th and 6th graders.
The kid’s eyes lit up as they entered the classroom and saw the set up.
Mr. Stidger promptly briefed the students on safety instructions and rules of conduct with the materials.
The class finished a whole 7 projects in one hour using the kit!
The kids compared dry ice and regular ice at room temperature and submerged in water.
They observed dry ice in a film container, and screamed in delight as the pressure popped the top and scared the Bejeebis out of the crowd. Then the students followed up by using water as a catalyst with dry ice in the said film container…and this time took shelter.
After this, the class put dry ice in a balloon, and observed the difference as they placed dry ice and water in a second balloon. I’m not sure who squealed louder, the dry ice or the kids, when they applied pressure with a spoon for “screaming cold ice.”
Mr. Stidger also demonstrated a “dancing bottle” using dry ice and an upside down 2 liter bottle, and what dry ice in water looks like if you put in just a few drops of dish soap.
Lastly, Mr. Stidger showed the class how dry ice can cause different mixtures to change color.
The kit was certainly a hit with the kids.
“My favorite experiment was screaming ice,” said Caley, 5th grade. “It was really funny.”
“This was a great unit that taught the basic principles of dry ice in a fun, exciting atmosphere,” said Stidger.
Here is the complete evaluation about the Spangler Dry Ice Kit in Mr. Stidger’s own words:
- Materials included for up to 6 groups
- I appreciated the lead in with what dry ice is, and the safety rules
- The sequence of the experiments from basic to elaborate made for an interesting progression
- The language is written so that it is easy to comprehend. Those who are not well versed in science would be able to understand the basic concepts, and more experienced practitioners could expand further if they wish.
- Most of the materials are in the kit. I thought that the ammonia water could have been packed as well. The term ammonia water threw me. Is regular ammonia and ammonia water the same?
- Consistency in measurement would make the instructions even easier. Some of the experiments used the metric system, others with tablespoons. Others did not.
- On that note, a milliliter measurement cup would have come in handy.Visit www.SteveSpanglerScience.com for more products and projects.Disclosure: This was not a paid review or endorsement. Summer Counts received the products for review, which we promptly donated to the classroom that participated.













